
It was a series of entirely predictable shocks. The certainties that have been touted for years, months and weeks prior to the announcement are sprinkled with a few choices that although not entirely out of left-field, are from left of centre.
Captaincy
Brian O’Driscoll can probably feel a little aggrieved not to get the chance to atone for the disappointment of New Zealand as captain and his main fault seems to be being a captain of the more eloquent and tranquil type rather than a simmering volcano of physicality that Ian McGeechan clearly desires. O’Driscoll doesn’t assume the disposition of a firebrand leader, but players under his captaincy are made to understand the importance the jersey they are wearing, be it blue, green or red in a placid but inspiring manner. Having Paul O’Connell lead the team is hardly likely to weaken it and it’s possibly best to be grateful for the fact that there are two leaders of such a high calibre available ahead of such a daunting tour.
Backs
Amongst the backs Byrne, Kearney, Williams, Fitzgerald, Bowe, Shanklin, O’Gara, Jones, Phillips, O’Leary and of course O’Driscoll all looked to have their names on tickets for some time so we move quickly on to the debatable selections. Leigh Halfpenny wasn’t entirely expected to travel but has been impressive in breaking into the Wales team along with in Cardiff Blues’ remarkable run in the Heineken Cup. He’s young, but what he lacks in experience at international level he makes up for in his capacity to do something spectacular. Ugo Monye also lacks the international experience, but his pace could come in very useful should the Lions’ wings struggle to cope with Bryan Habana and he’s probably worth bringing on tour.
It’s not often that an ideological debate surrounds the Lions, but Riki Flutey’s potential inclusion has sparked debates about what exactly a Lion is. He has already faced the Lions as a New Zealand Maori, but leaving aside the debate on nationality, should he be in the squad? I’m not convinced he’s a top class player, but he might just merit his place in the 37. James Hook may lack the out and out pace of Flutey, but given his all round game and versatility, I’d prefer to have him as a tourist and he can count himself unlucky not to travel.
The disappointment of not seeing Gordon D’Arcy in the squad is somewhat tempered by a dose of realism and the inclusion of Keith Earls. D’Arcy has battled back determinedly from injury, but his best work since the injury has come in the Magners League and although he has played at international level, he looked much less of a threat when at the higher standard. Somewhat conversely, Earls hasn’t had as much international game time, but his performances always give the impression of a really electric player who can do something brilliant in an instant.
When the name of Harry Ellis was called out was I the only person to think ‘wrong answer’? Obviously a Lions call up is based on judgement and it can’t be de facto incorrect, but I can’t help feeling that his inclusion is just wrong. Mike Blair is a far better player and whilst not at the peak of their powers this season, Dwayne Peel and Peter Stringer have aspects to their game that make them useful players to have on the bench if called upon.
Forwards
With twenty players vying for eight starting berths, the debate regarding the Lions pack has only just begun. The eyebrows did make an upward surge when Andy Powell got announced – with a couple of stirring carries masking a lack of a consistent contribution over 80 minutes, there’s a touch of the Chabals about him, but maybe his selection with a view to a role as impact sub is justified.
Phil Vickery hasn’t been at his best for a couple of years now, but there is no doubting that he is an excellent scrummager down through the years and that’s something that will be vital in matches that will feature referees adopting a Southern Hemisphere view of the rules. That’s probably why Ireland’s Grand Slam winning props have missed out. Although their contribution all over the pitch is generally excellent, Messers Horan and Hayes can occasionally look vulnerable at scrum time.
It’s not inconceivable that an all-Irish back row will line out for the 1st Test and it’s great to see that Stephen Ferris’ emergence has resulted in a call-up. Given that England’s lineout looked like it could be got at during the 6 Nations and strength of South Africa in this area, it’s a bit of a surprise to see Simon Shaw in there, but it looks like that he will be well down the pecking order for the Tests. Alan Quinlan’s selection was the biggest surprise of the lot, but considering his performances for Munster and his flexibility around the pack, having him in the squad isn’t entirely unmerited, but must be difficult to take for Ryan Jones who isn’t far behind him in the versatility stakes and is perhaps being unfairly scapegoated for the slight dip in Wales’ form.
My [admittedly biased ]starting XV for the 1st Test:
15. Byrne
14. Williams
13. O’Driscoll
12. Roberts
11. Bowe
10. Jones
9. Phillips
8. Heaslip
7. Wallace
6. Ferris
5. AW Jones
4. O’Connell
3. Murray
2. Flannery
1. Jenkins
Posted in Rugby, Sportsbook | 2 Comments »